Lab-Grown vs. Natural Diamonds: A Complete Guide from a Certified Gemologist

Choosing a diamond is one of the most meaningful investments you can make—whether it’s for an engagement, inheritance, or a personal milestone. But today's buyers face a modern dilemma:
Should you choose a lab-grown diamond or a natural diamond?

As a GIA Graduate Gemologist, Certified Master Appraiser, and private jeweler with over 20 years of experience, I’ve helped hundreds of clients make informed decisions. This guide walks you through:

• What lab-grown and natural diamonds are

• Their differences in value, ethics, and market perception

• Real pros and cons—no fluff

• How to choose what’s right for you

---

What Is a Lab-Grown Diamond?

A lab-grown diamond (also called lab-created, man-made, or synthetic diamond) is a real diamond created in a lab using technology that replicates Earth’s natural diamond-forming environment.

There are two methods:

• High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT): mimics Earth’s pressure and heat

• Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD): forms diamonds from carbon gas in thin layers

The result is a crystal that is identical to a natural diamond in optical, chemical, and physical properties.

✅ According to the Federal Trade Commission, lab-grown diamonds are legally defined as real diamonds.

---

What Is a Natural Diamond?

Natural diamonds are mined in every way from Earth, formed over 1 to 3 billion years under intense heat and pressure. They are unearthed from natural stone deposits, then cut, polished, and graded.

Each natural diamond is one-of-a-kind, with distinct inclusions and crystal patterns created by nature. These characteristics help appraisers determine origin, age, and value.

Learn more about grading natural diamonds at the Gemological Institute of America (GIA).

---

Are Lab Diamonds Really the Same?

In appearance and structure—yes. In perception and resale—no.

Both lab diamonds and natural diamonds are:

• Rated 10 on the Mohs hardness scale

• Graded using the 4Cs (Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat)

• Visually indistinguishable without advanced lab equipment

However, only natural diamonds are created in finite quantities and have a long-standing resale and investment history. Lab-created diamonds are increasingly common—and that affects how they’re perceived by insurers, collectors, and secondary markets.

---

Diamond Certification: GIA vs. IGI

Certification is key to knowing what you’re buying.

• GIA (Gemological Institute of America): Most respected for natural diamonds. Provides strict, consistent grading.

• IGI (International Gemological Institute): Known for certifying lab-grown diamonds.

Always request certification—whether you’re buying a 0.50ct solitaire or a 5.00ct diamond engagement ring.

---

Can You Tell the Difference?

To the naked eye, you cannot tell the difference between a lab-created diamond and a mined diamond. Even trained professionals often need spectroscopic equipment to determine origin.

Both diamonds:

• Are chemically and physically identical

• Sparkle the same

• Can be set in fine jewelry

• Will test as real on a diamond tester

However, inscriptions and lab reports will clarify the source.

---

Pros and Cons: Lab-Grown vs. Natural Diamonds

Here’s an honest breakdown based on real-world gemology, not marketing fluff.

---

💎 Lab-Grown Diamond Pros

• More Affordable: Typically 30–50% less than a comparable natural diamond.

• Real Diamond: Not a simulant—lab diamonds are real.

• Conflict-Free: No mining involved; produced in controlled labs.

• Environmentally Scaled: Avoids land displacement and mining damage.

• Customizable: Easier to find precise shapes, sizes, and matching stones.

💎 Lab-Grown Diamond Cons

• Often Produced Overseas: Primarily in India and China, where labor/environmental oversight may vary.

• Energy-Intensive: Especially HPHT methods, which consume large amounts of electricity.

• Little to No Resale Value: Because diamonds can be grown indefinitely, lab diamonds don’t hold scarcity-based value.

• Still Gaining Acceptance: Some jewelers, appraisers, and insurers treat them differently than natural stones.

---

💎 Natural Diamond Pros

• Investment Potential: Natural diamonds have historically appreciated or retained value.

• Finite Resource: Natural diamonds are created by Earth and are not reproducible.

• Tradition & Symbolism: Preferred for heirlooms, diamond engagement rings, and estate pieces.

• Established Market: Easier to insure, appraise, and resell or upgrade.

• Unique Fingerprint: Natural inclusions are like a diamond’s DNA—one of a kind.

💎 Natural Diamond Cons

• Higher Cost: Reflects rarity, demand, and mining costs.

• Ethical Concerns (Unless Verified): Look for conflict-free sourcing via the Kimberley Process.

• Environmental Impact: Mining can cause ecosystem disruption if not regulated.

---

Comparison Table: Lab vs. Natural Diamonds

---

Common Use Cases

💠 When to Choose a Lab-Grown Diamond

• Buying a diamond engagement ring on a budget

• Designing a custom piece with specific size requirements

• Gifting everyday diamond jewelry

• Prioritizing conflict-free diamonds

• Wanting a larger stone for less money

💍 When to Choose a Natural Diamond

• Shopping for investment-grade diamonds

• Creating a family heirloom

• Purchasing for an estate or legacy piece

• Wanting to pass jewelry down through generations

• Seeking resale or upgrade options in the future

---

What Buyers Get Wrong

1. Thinking lab diamonds will gain value
   They won’t. Lab-created diamonds are abundant and lack scarcity.

2. Believing "diamond" always means natural
   If a diamond isn’t labeled “natural,” assume it’s lab-grown or simulant.

3. Assuming all diamonds are ethical
   Always ask for conflict-free or origin-certified documentation.

4. Not requesting certification
   A diamond without a GIA or IGI report can be misrepresented.

---

Are Lab Diamonds Sustainable?

This is debated. While lab-grown diamonds avoid mining, their electricity use is substantial, especially in HPHT production. If the lab is powered by fossil fuels, the environmental benefit may be offset.

Some labs now use renewable energy, but that is not yet industry-wide. Ask your jeweler about the source and lab origin.

---

What About Simulants?

Let’s clarify:

---

Real-World Scenario: Engagement Ring Example

Client A wanted a 2.00ct G/VS2 round brilliant.

• Natural cost: $18,000

• Lab-grown cost: $6,800

Both looked identical. Client chose lab-grown to maximize size and put savings toward a honeymoon.

Client B wanted a vintage-style piece for her future daughter.

• Chose a 1.10ct natural diamond from the 1930s

• Paid $7,400 and had it re-set into a custom ring

Both made the right choice based on values—not marketing.

---

FAQs

Do lab diamonds test as real?

Yes. Lab-grown diamonds test as real using standard diamond testers.

Can natural diamonds be identified?

Yes. They usually come with GIA certification and may show natural inclusions or growth patterns.    

Are lab diamonds always cheaper?

Yes. On average, lab-created diamonds cost 30–70% less than natural stones of the same size and quality.

Can lab diamonds be insured?

Yes, but some insurers distinguish between lab and natural when offering coverage or valuation.

---

Still Not Sure?

Let’s simplify:

---

Explore More & Shop with Confidence

🔹 Shop IGI-Certified Lab-Grown Diamonds
🔸 Browse GIA-Certified Natural Diamonds
📘 GIA Diamond Education
📊 Rapaport Diamond Price Index
🌱 Brilliant Earth Conflict-Free Info
📜 FTC Jewelry Guidelines