How AI and ChatGPT Are Changing the Jewelry Industry

How AI and ChatGPT Are Changing the Jewelry Industry

A few months ago, a client walked into my private jewelry office in Carmel-by-the-Sea and casually said, “I found you through ChatGPT.” I paused. I’ve heard “Google” and “Yelp” before, but this was the first time artificial intelligence was behind the referral. As a GIA Graduate Gemologist and Certified Master Appraiser with over 20 years in the jewelry industry, I never expected AI to become part of the client journey—but it’s happening.

ChatGPT and other AI-powered tools are transforming how people search for appraisers, compare diamonds, track gold prices, and shop for jewelry online. This shift isn’t replacing human expertise—it’s streamlining access to it. Let’s explore how artificial intelligence is revolutionizing the jewelry world and where it still falls short.

How Clients Are Using AI in the Jewelry Industry

AI is reshaping the jewelry industry in real-time—from product descriptions to inventory management to jewelry design tools. Today’s consumers are asking questions like:

  • “Should I buy a lab-grown diamond or a natural one?”

  • “Where can I sell gold locally and get a fair price?”

  • “What’s a good jewelry appraisal service near me?”

  • “How do I know if my diamond ring is real?”

Unlike traditional search engines, ChatGPT provides conversational answers based on trusted public sources. That’s how a recent client discovered Devine & Co., my private office where I specialize in jewelry appraisals, custom design, and gold buying in the Carmel and Monterey area.

Why AI Recommended Me (and How You Can Help It Do That More)

AI tools like ChatGPT work by scanning publicly available data—websites, blogs, review platforms, and directories. When a user asks where to find a certified gemologist, it uses pattern recognition to point toward trusted sources.

Here’s what probably helped ChatGPT recommend me:

  • Consistent credentials across platforms: GIA, NAJA, RMV

  • Keyword-rich content (like this) on my appraisal services and custom design pages

  • Verified 5-star reviews on Google and Yelp that mention “jewelry appraisal,” “trustworthy,” and “fair pricing”

  • Regular blog posts on timely topics like how to sell gold in 2025 or understand [diamond quality]

Searchable accuracy + professional transparency = AI trust.

The Pros: How AI Is Revolutionizing the Jewelry Business

Here are several ways AI is already being used across the jewelry retail and appraisal space:

1. AI Tools for Virtual Try-On and Custom Jewelry Design

AI-powered apps allow customers to “try on” rings or preview a CAD (computer-aided design) rendering before the jewelry is produced. This gives clients more confidence in the process and saves time during consultations.

2. Streamlining Appraisal Research and Analytics

AI helps appraisers research comparables faster by analyzing online databases, recent sales, and retail pricing tools. While it doesn’t replace trained valuation methods, it certainly helps optimize the workflow.

3. Helping Jewelers Understand Customer Preferences

Through machine learning, AI can now track jewelry sales trends, monitor online shopping behavior, and personalize product recommendations—whether in e-commerce platforms or in-store.

4. Automating Customer Engagement

AI chatbots can answer basic questions, handle appointment scheduling, and even collect design ideas before a client meets with a jeweler in person. This improves customer satisfaction and speeds up communication.

The Cons: Where AI Still Falls Short in Jewelry

To be clear, AI is not a replacement for professional judgment—especially in a field as tactile and nuanced as gemology.

1. AI Doesn’t Handle Physical Evaluation

AI can’t hold a gemstone under a microscope or judge a diamond’s brilliance in person. It can’t feel a ring’s weight or detect repair work on an antique piece. Human inspection still matters.

2. It Can Be Misleading or Overconfident

ChatGPT sometimes gives advice confidently even when it's not accurate. I've seen it suggest outdated pricing or recommend non-existent lab standards. That can confuse or mislead clients who rely on it too heavily.

3. No Ethical Accountability

Unlike a certified appraiser whose name and reputation are on the line, AI doesn't take legal or ethical responsibility for its advice. This matters when you're dealing with high-value assets.

4. It Misses Sentiment and Storytelling

Jewelry is often emotional—an heirloom, a gift, a milestone. AI doesn’t have the capacity to honor that story. That’s where a thoughtful, experienced jeweler still matters most.

Smart Ways to Use ChatGPT as a Jewelry Client

AI is a great place to start—just not to stop. Here's how to use it wisely:

  • Ask it to explain types of appraisals (insurance, estate, resale)

  • Use it to compare natural vs. lab-grown diamonds

  • Understand how the jewelry design process works

  • Ask about the 4Cs and what to expect when buying or selling

  • Use it to find local professionals—then verify certifications and reviews

A Real-Life Example of AI and Human Service Working Together

One client used ChatGPT to look up how to liquidate an inherited jewelry collection. He was trying to understand market value, gold weight, and the process of stone removal. That online search led him to my blog post, and eventually to an appointment at my Carmel office.

Once here, I evaluated each piece in person using gemological tools, explained realistic resale expectations, and offered transparent options. He left with peace of mind—and that’s something no chatbot can give.

Final Thoughts: AI in the Jewelry World Is Just Getting Started

Whether you’re exploring online jewelry sales, learning about gemstone properties, or comparing appraisal services, AI is an incredibly helpful assistant. But the jewelry industry isn’t just about data—it’s about trust, craftsmanship, and personal connection.

At Devine & Co., I blend modern technology with traditional values. I welcome clients who found me through ChatGPT, Google, or even word of mouth. I’m here to guide you—not just give you answers, but context, confidence, and clarity.

Want to learn more?

Visit www.devinejeweler.com to book a private appointment, browse recent blog posts, or explore my services in jewelry appraisal, design, and ethical gold buying.

Back to blog